When poll is active respond at
Send tracyclark470 and your message to 22333
What stood out to you most from this research summary?
-
I was surprised to read how teachers who relied on what they learned in their preparation program, knew less about reading instruction.
-
What stood out the most to me about reading comprehension is that knowledge is what drives reading comprehension. This makes me reflect on the importance of building background knowledge.
-
What's most striking is the clear disconnect between college teacher preparation and real-world evidence: Teachers who relied most on their preservice college training actually scored the lowest on reading science knowledge, with only 2% pointing to their college degree as their main source of effective instruction skills. It's troubling that teacher preparation programs—the very institutions responsible for qualifying educators—have spent years sending new teachers into classrooms grounded in discredited methods like "three-cueing" (word-guessing). As a result, states and districts are left spending massive amounts of time and funding to retrain teachers on the job through programs like LETRS just to establish baseline literacy practices.
-
My biggest takeaway is that equity is not simply giving every student access to the same curriculum. It is ensuring every student has the KNOWLEDGE, vocabulary, instruction, and support necessary to access that curriculum. Our students deserve to be exposed to rich literature, complex texts, meaningful discussions, and experiences that expand their understanding beyond what they already know. We cannot lower the level of instruction because students lack background knowledge. Instead, we must be intentional about building that knowledge so they can successfully engage with grade-level learning. As a campus leader, this article challenges me to continue supporting teachers in finding that balance while ensuring we never lose sight of the bigger picture. We are not just teaching students to pass a reading assessment. We are building readers, thinkers, and learners who have the knowledge and confidence to understand and engage with the world around them. PHONICS is key.
-
What stood out most was that many teachers reported learning more about effective reading instruction on the job than in their college preparation programs. Another concern was that students in high-poverty schools may have less access to teachers who strongly support science-based reading instruction. The emphasis on background knowledge and vocabulary also stood out because it shows why science and social studies are essential to reading comprehension. Progress is encouraging, but schools need stronger training, consistent instruction, and content-rich lessons to help every child become a skilled reader.
-
The misunderstanding of the importance of ensuring students are engaged in reading non-fiction tests to support reading comprehension.
-
Professional identity is real, and pedagogical habits are deeply ingrained. Adults desire autonomy in teaching practices. Yes, but let's make sure students are learning to read.
-
I found this quote interesting, "But the research tells a different story. These generic comprehension strategies have very little transferable effect." There is such a strong focus on skills in isolation in upper grades and this makes me wonder what new direction we will need to go in.
-
What stood out most to me in the research article is the idea that college preparation programs are not necessarily equipping future teachers with the practical skills needed to effectively teach students. I also found it interesting that students develop stronger reading comprehension when they can draw on real-life experiences, build background knowledge, and create mental files of information that can be stored in long-term memory and retrieved when needed. This is much more meaningful than teaching students cookie-cutter strategies for dissecting a reading comprehension passage without truly understanding the content. It reinforces the importance of building knowledge and making meaningful connections rather than simply teaching students how to answer questions about what they read.
-
The thing that stands out to me the most is that it is difficult to shift existing mindsets. Teachers who originally were taught to use balanced literacy are having to shift their mindset and that is not an easy task. The following quote explains why. "Teachers who spent years building expertise in one approach, and who genuinely believed they were helping children, are being asked to fundamentally reimagine what good reading instruction looks like. That's not easy. Professional identity is real, and pedagogical habits are deeply ingrained."
-
I was shocked to read about challenge 3 and teacher misunderstanding comprehension. I think it is key that students gain background knowledge before diving into a text, however when students are given assessments, whether through the district or the state, the passages often are about topics that they have never heard of or interacted with, which sets them up for failure.
-
The percentage of teachers who chose strategies as being reading comprehension.
-
What stood out to me most was the gap between knowing the Science of Reading and actually putting it into practice. Teachers can receive all the training in the world, but it means very little if it doesn't translate into classroom instruction. My biggest takeaway is that we have to be intentional about how we teach reading and ensure our practices are truly grounded in research.
-
What stood out to me most was that only 2% of teachers learned about effective reading practices in their educator prep program. I found it shocking that so many teachers are still learning outdated methods of reading instruction.
-
It is extremely important that teachers continue their professional learning each year. The information about teachers reflecting on their college preparation was eye opening.
-
That reading comprehension depends primarily on "what students already know about the topic and the specific vocabulary used in a text."
-
What stood the most from this research is that reading instruction in high-poverty schools is weaker, the children who need the most get the least.
-
"The more a teacher relied on what they learned in their teacher preparation program, the less they knew about evidence-based reading instruction." stands out for me the most. I graduated 2011, after concurrently having worked at a Head Start Preschool for 5 years. When I took my certification exams, I realized that my experiences in a school setting helped me more than what I had learned in my preparation program when it came to passing my exams. Same was true with my preparation on helping students read. Through LETRS I have learned the specifics of evidence based-instruction, which has elevated my delivery of reading instruction.
-
What stood out to me was the emphasis on the driving forces for reading comprehension being tied to the students' comprehension about the material being read. What the student knows about historical events, art, special days, etc... helps them understand the overall comprehension picture when reading.
-
This sentence from the summary stood out the most "reading comprehension depends primarily on "what students already know about the topic and the specific vocabulary used in a text." I have always thought that reading comprehension meant using strategies such as, teaching students to summarize, make inferences, identify the main idea, visualize, etc.
-
What stood out to me most is that reading comprehension is not just about teaching students strategies or skills. Students need background knowledge, vocabulary, and meaningful opportunities to engage deeply with texts. This reminds me that building knowledge and language is just as important as teaching comprehension strategies, especially for English learners.
-
The need to focus on the lower grades as well, not just upper grades
-
I did attend a LETRS training and that training helped me understand what to focus on to help struggling readers advance. It is true that when I entered the teaching blocks at the university it did not prepare me for the classroom.
-
What stood out to me most was the idea that reading comprehension isn't just about teaching reading strategies, it's about building students' background knowledge and vocabulary. It really reinforced for me that strong instruction in science, social studies, and classroom discussions helps create better readers
-
The gap between teacher understandings for reading instruction between poverty and affluent schools is startling But, sadly, not surprising. It is a tale as old as time.
-
What stood out to me most was the finding that reading comprehension is not simply a set of skills that students can practice and apply to every text.
-
The lack of preparation we have in the university level, how teachers acredite their learning to PD.
-
That comprehension is based on what they know anad their use of vocabulary yet our state assessment is based on skills.
-
Teachers don't realize how everything in reading is connect to the goal of reading comprehension.
-
What stood out to me the most is that teachers who relied more on what they learned in college or university programs scored lower on the knowledge of reading quiz compared to teachers who relied on other sources.
-
Where it discussed how teachers thinking of reading comprehension is wrong.
-
Educator Preparation Programs are still failing our new teachers. This resonates because it seems the critical routines, core knowledge and skills a teacher needs to implement an instructional program effectively are not well addressed.
-
New teachers are not prepared to teaching in the classroom the reading phonological awareness until they go through training and develop experience in the classroom. The teachers that go through the training of Letrs, are doing better in the classroom teaching.
-
This research aligned with my own education as a preservice teacher. Our teachers need to come out with solid training so that whether a student is in a 1st year teacher's classroom or a 30-year classroom, they are getting equitable educational opportunities. The training matters.
-
It is not only about reading strategies, it is also about building the background knowledge for students.
-
What stood out to me was the lack of effective practices being taught in college and how teachers are learning most of what they know on the job.
-
I agree that most comprehension questions are associated with understanding different content areas. That is why our district has implemented the SDGs so our students have a concept of all aspects of life
-
Teachers not being prepared to teach reading to students.
-
We cannot assume teachers have the foundational knowledge needed to effectively teach reading, regardless of their years of experience. This makes our instructional leadership, PLCs, coaching, and walkthroughs even more important.
-
Teacher preparation programs are still failing new teachers
-
What stood out to me was that many new teachers are not aware or have a knowledge of the science of reading.
-
What stood out the most was challenge 1: Teacher preparation programs are still failing new teachers. I feel that this has been something that has been overlooked for decades; all of us who have taken teacher education classes have noticed that the programs we completed did not have practical application in our own classrooms.
-
High-poverty schools may have less access to teachers who are well prepared.
-
The amount of teachers surveyed that responded learning more on the job than in higher education institutions
-
What stood out was the amount of teachers in percentage that do not understand crystallized knowledge and when explained do not make the correlation to allowable experiences for students.
-
I agree that the Science of Reading has changed the way teachers are focusing on the foundations of reading . In the past we would expecpt students to sound out each word and see if they would make sense. We have now realized that we were wrong and need to explicitly teach phonics skills in order to achieve student reading success.
-
What was most interesting to me is the gap between what is taught in teacher preparation programs and real, day to day business of teaching. It is not surprising to me that most teachers respond that they learned more practical information on the job than in their preparation program.
-
The point that stood out to me most was that teacher preparation programs continue to fall short in adequately preparing new teachers for the classroom, even though we have a robust body of research outlining how students learn to read. This made me think about both teacher retention and the challenge of attracting people to the profession if their training does not equip them for the job. If teacher preparation programs placed a stronger emphasis on evidence-based reading instruction and how to teach students to read effectively, novice teachers might feel more confident and less overwhelmed as they begin their careers.
-
The gap around phonics in high-poverty settings. Teachers are less informed and committed to science of teaching reading. I think that the teachers are so overwhelmed with students and their current situations that they are just trying to do what is best for students.
-
What stood out the most to me from this research summary is that even as phonics knowledge has improved through the Science of Reading instruction, many teachers still view reading comprehension as a set of transferable skills such as main idea, rather than something heavily dependent on a student's background knowledge and vocabulary development.
-
There is an evident shift towards the Science of Reading in schools, but this is still a process. Educational personnel still need updated, adequate information to set them up for success in the Early Literacy classrooms.
-
How teachers are coming into. the field after graduating not being prepared for the job.
-
What stood out to me the most was the percentage of teachers that aren't prepared when coming out of college but I am not surprised. I think that experience in the classroom and on the job training is where you truly find out what works.
-
The science of reading is supported by data and is very impactful, yet schools have been slow to adopt it and lack of training and application still needs to be addressed.
-
Challenge 2: Students that come from under-resourced homes de[end on their teachers, and materials at school.They do not have access to books at homke, educated parents and ways to enrich their bakgound knowledge.
-
My biggest takeaway is that being a good reading teacher means being willing to change how we teach when research shows us that children need something different. Our responsibility is not just to teach the reading curriculum. It is to make sure children leave our classrooms knowing how to read.
-
The thing that stood out the most to me was the gap in phonics among high poverty schools. Not only is the gap with the students but the teachers as well. These students are depending on their teachers for other things like experiences to build background knowledge.
-
The most important takeaway from this research is that teachers who understand and use Science of Reading practices are better equipped to help students learn to read successfully.
-
Only 2% of teachers said their preservice program was where they learned the most about effective reading practices.
-
The most important takeaway from this research is that teachers who understand and use Science of Reading practices are better equipped to help students learn to read successfully.
-
That teaching reading is still changing, teachers aren't prepared, and the students who do not have experiences and back ground knowledge are the ones who are suffering the most.
-
The biggest takeaway for me was that teacher knowledge directly impacts student achievement. The article states that teachers who have a strong understanding of the Science of Reading are better equipped to provide effective reading instruction. It emphasizes the importance of ongoing professional development and ensuring teachers have a solid understanding of phonics, decoding, vocabulary, and language development. It is important not to assume that your years of teaching experience translates into effective teaching. As campus leaders, we must continue to invest in building teachers' instructional knowledge and skills to ensure they are equipped to provide quality instruction that impacts student learning and achievement.
-
What stood out to me the most was that about comprehension. We have been teaching our students many reading strategies and they learn them well, but many of our students lack knowledge on many topics.
-
I resonated with the article when it referred that college doesn't prepare you for the classroom. I was 1 of those college student that was not prepared for the classroom after graduating.
-
Everything was understandable and relevant but it did not address how we are able to accomplish all this in the minimal time that we have to roll it out
-
What stood out to me the most was how our teacher preparation programs are still failing new teachers. Seeing the data reflect that only 2 percent of teachers say they learned about effective practices for teaching children to read from their preservice preparation programs is a frightening statistic. I am curious to know if that percentage is the same in Texas.
-
What stood out to me was the preservice knowledge gained on STR for our graduating teachers. We are counting on our IHE partners to graduate the very best. What if these were surgeons or pilots understanding a science that was crucial to their work? Do we want them to learn "on the job"? Yikes!
-
What stood out the most to me about this summary is the belief that new teachers are taught and prepared to come into a classroom with the best research-based practices to teach the students. But unfortunately, that's not what findings show. Most teachers said they learned more on the job than in their pre-service program.
-
What stood out to me most was that 58% of teachers still view reading comprehension primarily as a set of generalizable skills rather than something developed through background knowledge and vocabulary. It made me reflect on how we approach Tier 1 instruction and curriculum internalization. We need to ensure our teachers are not simply teaching isolated reading skills but are intentionally building knowledge through meaningful, content-rich instruction. This is particularly important in our early grades, where we are laying the foundation for students to become successful readers.
-
A mindset change is slowing the progress of effective reading instruction due to buy-in issues and misinformed/unprepared instructional staff.
-
My key takeaway was that reading comprehension relies heavily on background knowledge and vocabulary, not just reading strategies. Ultimately, this research reminded me that our responsibility as school leaders is not just to ensure teachers are teaching reading, but to ensure students are actually learning how to read.
-
What stood out most was that 58% of teachers viewed reading comprehension as a set of general skills rather than as something developed through background knowledge and vocabulary. As a reading interventionist, I see how important it is for students to understand what they read, not just identify the main idea or make inferences. Students need vocabulary, background knowledge, and meaningful exposure to different subjects to build strong comprehension. This research reinforces the importance of providing explicit reading instruction while also building students' knowledge across science, social studies, and other content areas.
-
The research finding that showed only 2 percent of teachers felt that their teacher preparation program helped them learn about effective practices to teaching students to read.
-
What stood out the most to me was when the article said that we focus on teaching individual reading skills like main idea and how that isn't what helps a child be a good reader.
-
That teaching prep programs are failing new teachers
-
The section that stood out to me most was the discussion about reading comprehension. I have always thought of skills such as identifying the main idea, making inferences, and summarizing as important comprehension skills. This article helped me think more deeply about how much comprehension also depends on students' background knowledge and vocabulary.
-
What stood out the most was that reading comprehension depends heavily on students' background knowledge and not just reading strategies.
-
The biggest takeaway for me is that we should not just teach students how to read words; we must also help them understand what they are reading.
-
What was most interesting to me about this article is the fact, that research shows one thing and yet our programs preparing educators are not utilizing this research to best prepare our future educators. Once again, this falls on districts to prepare our educators with the latest research and finding the time to provide these trainings all whilst aligning the adopted curriculum.
-
What stood out to me the most was that teacher preparatory programs are not preparing teachers for how to teach reading in the classroom.
-
Reading comprehension does not only rely on finding the main idea, summarizing, and making inferences and teach reading using content rich text:
-
What stood out to me was that there are teacher preparation gaps coming out of the universites and the way teachers are viewing comprehension.
-
What stood out the most from this research summary was the fact that "Only 42 percent correctly identified that reading comprehension depends primarily on "what students already know about the topic and the specific vocabulary used in a text."
-
1. Teacher preparation: Many college teacher-preparation programs are not adequately preparing teachers to teach evidence-based reading instruction. 2. High-poverty schools: Teachers in high-poverty schools are less likely to prioritize phonics over cueing, putting students who need strong reading instruction most at risk. 3. Reading comprehension: Many teachers misunderstand comprehension. Understanding what students read depends greatly on vocabulary and background knowledge, not just practicing strategies like finding the main idea or making inferences. 4. Changing teaching practices: Some teachers have embraced the Science of Reading, while others still rely on traditional balanced literacy and three-cueing practices.
-
What stood out to me most from the research was that students need background knowledge and vocabulary to understand what they read. Practicing skills such as identifying the main idea or making inferences alone does not provide the background needed to understand every new topic. I saw this firsthand this weekend during our district UIL meet. In the listening event, students heard a selection about the Texas rodeo. Living near the border, some of our students may have had fewer experiences with rodeos than students from communities where these events are more familiar. Although a livestock show takes place annually in a city about 20 minutes away, living nearby does not necessarily mean students have attended or know the vocabulary associated with it. This experience helped me recognize how differences in background knowledge can affect comprehension, even when students are listening carefully. It also reinforced the importance of building that knowledge in the classroom through content-rich texts, pictures, discussions, and vocabulary instruction so all students have opportunities to make meaningful connections.
-
58 % of Teachers misunderstand reading comprehension. University programs are correlated with lower knowledge of evidence-based reading instruction. Only 2 percent of surveyed K–3 teachers reported learning most about effective practices in college preparation, showing a deep structural disconnect between higher education curricula and literacy science.
-
Challenge 1: Teacher preparation programs are still failing new teachers
-
It was so surprised that only 2% of teachers said they learned about effective practices for teaching children to read from their preparation programs. Teacher preparation programs should be aligned with the Science of Reading to better prepare new teachers.
-
What stood out to me the most was that reading comprehension is not simply about teaching strategies, but about building students' background knowledge, vocabulary, and understanding of what they read. Students need knowledge about a topic to successfully apply skills such as identifying the main idea, making inferences, and summarizing.
-
Challenge 3: Teachers still misunderstand reading comprehension- After reading this section, I feel like we are still lacking in this area. We focus a lot on generalized skills, such as main idea, etc.
-
• In a striking failure of higher education, teachers who relied most on their university preparation programs scored lower on the science of reading knowledge quiz than those who relied on any other source. Only 2% of teachers credited their college program as their primary source of effective reading practices, meaning formal teacher preparation is actively serving as a bottleneck to literacy progress.
-
What stood out to me most was that reading comprehension goes beyond teaching skills like finding the main idea and making inferences; students also need strong background knowledge and vocabulary to truly understand what they read. It also reminded me how important it is for teachers to continue learning and using research-based strategies to help all students become successful readers.
-
What stood out to me was the fact that 33% of teachers surveyed felt that they learned more from learned the most about effective reading practices than their preservice preparation service.
-
"Among teachers in high-poverty settings, 43 percent failed to express a clear preference for phonics over cueing, compared to 25 percent in low-poverty schools. That means nearly half of teachers in the schools that serve the most vulnerable children are ambivalent about the single most evidence-supported element of early literacy instruction."
-
What stood out to me most from this research summary is that what actually drives comprehension is knowledge. It makes sense.
-
Teachers in high-poverty schools are, on average, less informed about and committed to reading science than their colleagues in more affluent settings.
-
58% of teachers still misunderstand what drives reading comprehension. The research reinforces the importance of building background knowledge and academic vocabulary. This is also stands out to me because the research highlights why science and social studies are essential to developing strong readers.
-
What stood out to me the most was that teachers who truly understand the science of reading have better outcomes with students. If we as teachers understand the science of reading, then we are able to truly keep our students engaged with the topic and have them fully understand the topic as well.
-
What stood out to me is the importance of building background knowledge and vocabulary to strengthen reading comprehension. Students need more than just reading strategies; they need meaningful opportunities to develop knowledge and make connections to what they read.
-
What stood out to me most was that only 2% of teachers reported learning about effective practices for teaching children during their teacher preparation courses. This highlights an opportunity to strengthen how we prepare and support teachers for success in the classroom.
-
For many teachers, college essentially taught them nothing useful. In some cases, that "preparation" may have actively pointed them toward discredited practices like three-cueing.
-
Teachers are not always adequately prepared to teach reading. I found it surprising that teachers who relied most on their college preparation programs scored lower on their knowledge of evidence-based reading instruction. This shows how important ongoing professional development is, even for experienced teachers. Changing instructional practices is not easy. Teachers may be comfortable with strategies they have used for years, especially if they believed those strategies were helping students. However, we have to be willing to reflect, learn, and adjust our instruction when research shows us more effective ways to support students. Overall, what stood out to me most was that teaching children to read involves much more than practicing reading strategies. We must explicitly teach foundational reading skills while also building vocabulary, background knowledge, and comprehension. As educators, we have to be willing to grow and make instructional decisions based on what research shows is best for our students.
-
The definition for reading comprehension stood out, because NOW it's saying that it = "what students already know about a topic and the specific vocabulary used in the text." But, it is usually taught as a set of skills students are able to apply as they read; for example, finding the main idea in a passage.
-
Whenever I read anything about the Science of Reading, I am always notice the misconceptions of balanced literacy. I understand why over time, practices get lost in translation. It makes me wonder what misconceptions will happen over the Science of Reading and how we can prevent them. The current misconception is that Science of Reading focuses mainly on phonics. I also wonder what the time frame for change really is in any practices whether that be medicine, law or education. How long does it take our higher institutions to catch up to real world applications. Is it three, five or ten years?
-
What stood out the most to me was Fig. 15 and the percentages that show how teachers have learned about effective practices of teaching children how to read.
-
The acknowledgement of teaching programs failing to prepare future teachers for the job.
-
Challenge #3 , the fact that teachers still misunderstand reading comprehension.
-
It is impressive to see the percentage of teachers who are impacted by the four challenges contained in this article. However, this is a reality that we must face, and the first step is acknowledging we have an issue in the way we teach reading.
-
Only 42 percent correctly identified that reading comprehension depends primarily on "what students already know about the topic and the specific vocabulary used in a text." It's only because of experience students can connect to their reading. That really doesn't happen when you have children in poverty, they don't have those experiences.
-
what stood out to me most is that comprehension is not just based on strategies, but it is further based on schema or knowledge of the students in combination with the text evidence and vocabulary and content rich texts that determines higher comprehension.
-
What stood out is that there is still so much work to be done to bridge literacy gaps.
-
Teachers in high-poverty schools are, on average, less informed about and committed to reading science than their colleagues in more affluent settings. Only 2 percent of teachers said their preservice program was where they learned the most about effective reading practices.
-
Ensuring our teachers, new and veteran have the appropriate research and information to support K-3 learners.
-
When teachers were asked to choose between two statements about reading comprehension, 58 percent chose the wrong one. They believed that reading comprehension is "a set of generalizable skills (like finding the main idea and making inferences) that can be applied to most texts." Only 42 percent correctly identified that reading comprehension depends primarily on "what students already know about the topic and the specific vocabulary used in a text.
-
A deep understanding of the science of teaching reading is what is required to really move the needle for developing great thinkers.
-
Colleges and universities aren't preparing teachers for reading instruction.
-
Students in high poverty schools who rely on teachers and need the most get the least when reading instruction is weak.
-
Teachers at high poverty schools experience apathy towards phonics even when students struggle. This is critical and leadership moves must be made to shift the mindset and ensure students most in need are becoming grade level readers.
-
Science is evolving how we think about how the brain learns to make sense of reading. As educators, it's our job to keep up with the science so we can do great things for kids.
-
Vocabulary and background knowledge play a huge role in reading comprehension.
-
One thing that stood out to me was the amount of teachers who are leaving college unprepared to teach. That's very shocking. In addition that amount of teachers who do not understand the science of teaching reading and how to truly teach comprehension.
-
The thing that stood out the most was the misconceptions teachers have about reading comprehension. Also, how poorly teachers are prepared when leaving their programs.
-
One thing that stands out most is that only 2% of teachers said their preservice teacher-preparation program was where they learned the most about effective reading instruction. By comparison, 33% said they learned the most on the job, and 21% through in-service professional development. That stood out because it suggests many teachers may enter the classroom without feeling fully prepared to teach reading using evidence-based practices. It also shows why ongoing coaching and professional development can be so important after teachers begin working.
-
58% of teachers surveyed chose the wrong answer about the meaning of reading comprehension.
-
The two areas that really made me pause was the gaps among students and the gaps in teacher understanding. Having worked in high-poverty schools my entire career, I've seen how students may be most at risk because they often have fewer resources outside of school to support literacy. However, what concerned me most was that teachers are also more likely to show gaps in understanding evidence-based reading instruction, particularly phonics. Together, these findings are very concerning.
-
Teachers who understand the science of reading produce better outcomes for students.
-
Science and Social Studies are critical to vocabulary acquisition and building background knowledge and should not be minimized or reduced for other things.
-
What stood out most was the equity concern. Students in high-poverty schools may be the most dependent on strong reading instruction, yet their teachers were more likely to be uncertain about phonics versus cueing. This reinforces the need for consistent, evidence-based reading instruction for all students.
-
What stood out most to me is that teachers are not prepared for teaching reading following their teacher prep programs. We see this year after year as new teachers join our campus and profession. This is compounded by folks that are still in prep programs and are coming to us as instructors instead of certified teachers. This places such importance on the need for job-embedded professional development and leadership on the campus that can support the learning daily.
-
I think the thing that stood out to me the most was teachers understanding of what reading comprehension is and how it differs so heavily from what Science of Reading says is reading comprehension. Teachers mistook strategies for comprehending as the definition of comprehension.
-
ThePedagogical Pushback stood out the most as I hear that often through the hallways but to see it in research is eye-opening. Veteran teachers who know "balanced literacy," know the data and results from that strucure so they are still hesistant when it comes to structured literacy. It is going to take several years of consistent implementation and results for teachers to "buy in."
-
The part that stood out to me most was the emphasis on knowledge. Especially in our setting, we have students who may not have the same background experiences or opportunities to build knowledge outside of school. It really made me think about how important it is for our teachers to intentionally build that background knowledge through what we teach, rather than assuming students already have it. We can't just teach the strategy, we have to give them the knowledge to make the strategy work.
-
Teachers who understand the science of reading produce better outcomes for students.
-
The information about reading comprehension and the percentage of teacher who did not correctly identify it
-
What stood out to me most was the finding that 58% of teachers still view reading comprehension primarily as a set of generalizable skills rather than something built through background knowledge and vocabulary. As an instructional leader, this makes me think about the difference between having strong instructional materials and actually understanding the research behind them. We can provide teachers with HQIM, but if teachers still approach comprehension primarily through isolated skills like main idea, inference, and summarizing, we may not get the intended impact. It reinforces the importance of professional learning that helps teachers understand not just what to teach, but why the curriculum is designed the way it is.
-
What stood out for me from the research summary is that evidence supports background knowledge and vocabulary as more important to reading comprehension than the skills we teach (such as making inferences, finding main idea and details, etc).
-
On a Title I campus, this reinforces the importance of making sure all of our students have access to rich content, vocabulary, and experiences at school. We cannot assume that every student comes to a text with the same background knowledge, so we have to be intentional about building that knowledge through strong Tier I instruction.
-
What stood out to me is the comment on Science of Reading momentum. I think there is a good chance that momentum could dissipate before teachers become really effective with it and students get the full benefits from Science of Reading instruction. There is a lot of learning left to do. If I am being completely transparent, as a district we did the Reading Academy modules but really did not do much with the learning. I wish we would continue the learning from the modules more intentionally.
-
Reading instruction should include both explicit, systematic phonics and comprehension. Over the years, I have seen the pendulum swing between narrowly focused approaches and whole language instruction. Students need strong foundational skills to read the words, along with vocabulary, language development, and comprehension instruction to understand what they read. I also believe teacher preparation needs more attention. Too many teachers enter the classroom without enough practical training in how to teach reading. College and certification programs should provide a stronger foundation, meaningful classroom practice, and opportunities to connect research to instruction. Our teachers deserve the preparation and ongoing support needed to help every student become a successful reader.
-
It is alarming how our teacher preparation programs are failing those who will be in America's classrooms trying to teach our children to read.
-
What stood out to me the most is how teachers in high poverty stricken schools do not favor phonics instruction, they favor cueing.
-
Most teachers said that they learned more from on the job training than their teaching programs or even college experience. I also thought the fact that there is a misunderstanding behind what comprehension actually is and how to teach it. I found truth in the fact that many teachers go back to the age old balanced literacy because that is what they were used to.
-
Several things stood out to me. The teacher prep programs can benefit a new teacher if they provide support and strong reading instruction, however we have had several teachers who have gone through some of the alternate online ones that receive little to no support. I have been a CIS for many years and have had to do more foundational training for reading than in years past. This goes along with teachers not understanding how to teach reading comprehension or even understanding important components. I went through some of the LETRS training and it was so insightful! We seem to make reading more complex with some of the reading programs that focus more on skills separately. We used to push background knowledge and I agree with the article, a lot of teachers don't understand the importance of it. The high poverty finding is not surprising because many times these are the students who lack experiences with content.
-
We still have considerable work to do in both changing mindsets AND building teacher skill for teaching students how to read.
-
Children who come from under-resourced homes depend on their teachers more than children who have compensating resources at home such as books, educated parents, and other enriching experiences that build background knowledge. When the reading instruction in high-poverty schools is weaker, the children who need the most get the least.